Shielding
What the environment becomes behind a spacecraft wall. A wall removes some particles, slows others, and makes new ones.
What a wall does
Shielding is not a filter. A wall stops low-energy particles outright and slows the rest. But an energetic proton or nucleus that hits a nucleus in the wall breaks it up, and the fragments come out the far side: neutrons, gamma rays, pions, lighter nuclei. Electrons radiate X-rays as they stop.
So behind a wall there are fewer of some particles and more of others. For solar particle events, which are soft, a wall helps a great deal. For galactic cosmic rays, which are hard, the first few g/cm² barely change the dose, and the neutrons made in a thick wall can make matters worse.
Thickness is given as areal density, in g/cm²: what matters is how much material a particle crosses, not how many millimeters. One g/cm² of aluminum is 3.7 mm.
How we model it
- Method
- Geant4 11.4.1 with the QBBC physics list: a spherical aluminum shell under isotropic irradiation, 0.3 to 30 g/cm².
- Checked against
- The MSL/RAD cruise dose, and SHIELDOSE-2 for protons.
- Expect
- See the validation results.
We ran Geant4 Agostinelli et al. (2003) Allison et al. (2006) Allison et al. (2016) once, ahead of time, and saved the answer as response matrices. Folding a spectrum through a matrix takes a few milliseconds in a browser.
- Geometry. An empty sphere of 50 cm radius inside an aluminum shell, at 0.3, 1, 3, 10 and 30 g/cm².
- Source. Particles start on the outer surface with the angular distribution of an isotropic field outside.
- What is recorded. The track length of every particle that crosses the interior, by species and energy. That gives the fluence inside per unit fluence outside.
- Incident particles. Protons, helium, carbon, oxygen, neon, magnesium, silicon, iron, electrons, photons and neutrons, in five energy bins per decade.
- Physics. The QBBC physics list, with a 0.1 mm production cut. A transparent shell returns the identity to 1 to 3 %.
Each outside species is folded through its matrix. Nuclei without a matrix of their own use the nearest heavier simulated nucleus, with the charges of the fragments shifted to match.
Inside means the interior average. A point off center sees parts of the wall at a slant, so its particles crossed more material. For thin walls and soft spectra the average over the interior is 0.6 to 0.8 of the value at the exact center. For penetrating radiation it is close to 1.
Assumptions and limits
- The field outside is taken as isotropic, and so is everything in it. The Sun is a beam; a real spacecraft is not a sphere and has a spread of thicknesses around every point. For that, combine several thicknesses, or run Geant4 on real geometry with the Python engine.
- Only aluminum is precomputed. The Python engine can build matrices for other materials.
- Hadronic models carry 10 to 30 % uncertainty in what they produce, more for light fragments.
- Fragment channels seen fewer than three times in the simulation are dropped as noise.
- The browser uses a packed copy of the matrices: output bins merged to five per decade and values rounded to steps of 0.06 in the logarithm. It agrees with the Python fold within 6 %.
- Protons below 1 MeV, electrons below 10 keV and photons below 1 keV are taken as stopped.
A cross-check
At the distance of Mars, in quiet times at φ = 480 MV, behind 10 g/cm² of aluminum:
| Method | Dose in water |
|---|---|
| Matrix fold: charged point dose plus the neutral dose in a sphere | 0.47 mGy/day |
| Direct Geant4 run, mean over a water sphere of 10 cm radius | 0.38 ± 0.02 mGy/day |
| Direct Geant4 run, sphere of 2 cm radius (few events) | 0.58 ± 0.22 mGy/day |
A body-sized sphere shields its own interior, so its mean dose sits below the point dose, as it should.
Sources
| Used for | Source | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Transport: Geant4 11.4.1, QBBC reference physics list, 0.1 mm production cut | Agostinelli et al. (2003); Allison et al. (2006); Allison et al. (2016) | code |
| Python bindings | geant4_pybind 0.1.3 geant4_pybind 0.1.3 | code |
| Data sets: EMLOW 8.8, PARTICLEXS 4.2, PhotonEvaporation 6.1.3, RadioactiveDecay 6.1.4, ENSDFSTATE 3.0, SAIDDATA 2.0, ABLA 3.3, INCL 1.3 | Geant4 11.4 data sets Geant4 collaboration (via conda-forge packages) | data |
| Ion stopping: proton S (Geant4) × Barkas effective charge Z[1 − exp(−125βZ^−2/3)]² | Barkas (1963) | standard |
| Electron collision stopping power, density-effect parameters | ICRU Report 37 (1984); Sternheimer et al. (1984) | standard |
| Quality factor Q(L) | ICRP Publication 60 (1991) | standard |
| Validation: GCR dose in transit to Mars (Si 0.332 ± 0.023, plastic 0.461 ± 0.092 mGy/day; 1.84 ± 0.33 mSv/day) | Zeitlin et al. (2013); Guo et al. (2015) | primary measurement |
| Validation: absorbed dose in the Columbus module of the ISS, 195 to 360 µGy/day across 11 locations, and a mean quality factor of 3.3 ± 0.1 | Berger et al. (2016) DOSIS passive dosimeters | primary measurement |